Diplomatic Protection: the Interpretation of International Legal Clauses of the Exhaustion of Local Remedies
https://doi.org/10.24833/0869-0049-2016-3-77-85
Abstract
The requirement of exhaustion of local remedies in the host State is one of the basic conditions to realize the right of diplomatic protection. The article reveals the mechanism in detail and ensure compliance with this principle in the host State and the consequences of non-compliance with this requirement for injured person and for states (host state and state of nationality). To ensure the legal base of this principle are analyzed in detail the international conventions and arbitrage practice.
Keywords
дипломатическая защита,
местные средства правовой защиты,
государство пребывания,
государство нарушитель,
Проект статей КМП о дипломатической защите 2006 г,
Diplomatic protection,
the host State,
responsible State,
the ILC Draft Articles on Diplomatic Protection 2006 Ambatielos case,
local remedies
References
1. Проект статей КМП о дипломатической защите 2006 г., ст. 1.
2. Абашидзе А.Х., Ильяшевич М.В. Дипломатическая защита в современном международном праве // Московский журнал международного права. - № 2. - 2015. - С. 54, 98.
3. Колодкин Р.А. К вопросу о дипломатической защите // Московский журнал международного права. - №1. 2007. - С. 108-125.
4. Нагиева А. Дипломатическая защита бипатридов. Московский журнал международного права. - № 2. -2015. - С. 63-75.
5. Mavrommatis Palestine Concessions Case, 1924, P.C.I.J., Ser. A, No. 2. P. 12.
6. M.N. Shaw. International Law. Sixth Ed. Cambridge. 2008. P. 819.
7. С. Amerasinghe. Local Remedies in International Law. Cambridge. 2005. P. 4.
8. Greece v. UK. 12 UN RIAA. 1956. P. 83.
9. I.C.J.Reports. 1959. P. 27.
10. I.C.J.Reports. 1989. P.42.
11. Vattel E. The Law of Nations or the Principles of Natural Law. Classics of International Law. 1916. P. 136.
12. PCIJ Series A No.2 . Jurisdiction. 1924. P.12.
13. PCIJ Series A/B No 76. 1938. P. 16.
14. Greece v. UK. 12 UN RIAA. 1956. P. 119.
15. C. de Visscher. Denial of Justice in International Law. 1935. 52 Hague Recueill. P. 422.
16. The «Kronprins Gustaf Adolf» (Sweden|USA). Decision of 18 July 1932// RIAA - 2006- Vol.II. P.1299. URL: www.un.org.
17. Case of certain Norwegian loans (France v. Norway). Judgment of 6 July 1957 // ICJ Reports 1957. P. 26> URL: www.icj-cij.org.
18. Waste Management Inc. V. United Mexican States, Award of 2 June 2000, No. ARB (AF)/98/2. P.228, para. 18. URL: www.icsid.worldbank.org
Review
For citations:
Nagieva A.A. Diplomatic Protection: the Interpretation of International Legal Clauses of the Exhaustion of Local Remedies. Moscow Journal of International Law. 2016;(3):77-85. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/0869-0049-2016-3-77-85
Views:
1335
Email this article 