Problems of the Applicable Law Determining in Intestate Succession Cases in Russia and Foreign Countries

The article refers to the issues of applicable law determination for intestate succession cases in Russia and is seeking for feasible solutions basing on foreign experience. The goal of the research consists in finding the ways to improve the Russian private international law in force. For the purpose, the authors have conducted a comparative analysis of the advantages and the disadvantages of the Russian and foreign legal acts containing intestate succession conflict of laws rules. The introduction focuses on the essence of the difficulties related to the unification of intestate succession legal regulation. The main part of the article outlines the imperfections of the Civil code of the Russian Federation, such as dépéçage of the conflict of laws rule and connecting factor of last residence that does not always allow to apply the law that is really connected to the hereditary relation. The following part provides the insights of the intestate succession conflict of laws regulation in the Hague Convention on the Law Applicable to Succession to the Estates of Deceased Persons concluded on August 1st, 1989 and in Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012 on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of decisions and acceptance and enforcement of authentic instruments in matters of succession and on the creation of a European Certificate of Succession. The conflict of laws regulation of these acts leads to the conclusion that the valid article 1224 of the Russian Civil code could be improved. For instance, the authors suggest to apply the closest connection principle and to implement the principle of the unity of the succession in Russian private international law.

intestate succession, applicable law, the closest connection, Regulation EU , the Hague Convention

1. Abramenkov M.S. Nasledovanie kak raznovidnost’ universal’nogo pravopreemstva: teoreticheskie i prakticheskie problemy v aspekte mezhdunarodnogo chastnogo prava [Inheritance as a kind of universal succession: theoretical and practical problems in the aspect of international private law] // Zhurnal rossijskogo prava. – 2007. – № 11.

2. Abramenkov M.S. Problemy kollizionno-pravovogo regulirovaniya nasledstvennyh pravootnoshenij v sovremennom mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave [Problems of conflict of laws regulation in hereditary relations in modern private international law]: avtoreferat na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kandidata yuridicheskih nauk: 12.00.03. Moscow, 2007.

3. Botancov D.V., Malkin O.Yu. Primenenie notariusami kollizionnyh norm v sfere nasledstvennyh otnoshenij [Use of conflict of laws rules in the field of inheritance relations by notaries] // Aktual’nye problemy prava: materialy IV mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii (g. Moskva, noyabr’ 2015 g.). – M: Buki-Vedi, 2015.

4. Brun M.I. Vvedenie v mezhdunarodnoe pravo [Introduction to international law]. Petrograd: Tipografiya V.F. Kirshbauma, 1915.

5. Grazhdanskij kodeks Rossijskoj Federacii. Postatejnyj kommentarij k razdelu V: Nasledstvennoe pravo [Civil code of the Russian Federation. Commentary to section V: Inheritance law] / Pod red. P.V. Krasheninnikova. – Moscow: Statut, 2013.

6. Grazhdanskij kodeks Rossijskoj Federacii. Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo. Postatejnyj kommentarij k razdelu VI [Civil code of the Russian Federation. Private international law. Commentary to section VI] / Pod red. P.V. Krasheninnikova. – Moscow: Statut, 2014.

7. Kabatova E.V. Izmenenie roli kollizionnogo metoda v mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave [Change of the role of conflict of laws method in private international law] / Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: sovremennaya praktika / Pod red. M.M. Boguslavskogo i A.G. Svetlanova. – M.: TON – Ostozh’e, 2000.

8. Kommentarij k Grazhdanskomu kodeksu Rossijskoj Federacii. Chast’ tret’ya (postatejnyj) [Commentary to the Civil code of the Russian Federation. Part three]. 2-e izdanie / pod red. A.P. Sergeeva. – Moscow: Prospekt, 2015.

9. Medvedev I.G. Kommentarij k konvenciyam v oblasti imushchestvennyh otnoshenij suprugov i nasledovaniya [Commentary to the conventions in the field of property relations of spouses and inheritance]. Moscow: Volters Kluver, 2007.

10. Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: uchebnik [Private international law: textbook] / otv. red. N.I. Marysheva. – Мoscow: Yurist, 2004.

11. Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo: uchebnik V 2 t. T.2: Osobennaya chast’ [Private international law: textbook. In 2 v. Volume 2: Special part] / MGIMO (U) MID Rossii; [otv. red. S.N. Lebedev, E.V. Kabatova] / Medvedev I.G. Glava 12 «Nasledstvennoe pravo». – M.: Statut, 2015.

12. Morun N. Mezhdunarodnoe nasledovanie vo Francii i Rossii: soderzhanie i vliyanie Reglamenta ES 650/2012 [International inheritance in France and Russia: the content and impact of EU Regulation 650/2012] // Notarius. – 2013. – № 6.

13. Nastol’naya kniga notariusa: V 4 t. T.4: Mezhdunarodnoe chastnoe pravo, ugolovnoe pravo i process v notarial’noj deyatel’nosti [Reference book of the notary: In 4 v. Vol. 4: Private international law, criminal law and procedure in notarial activities] / Pod red. I.G. Medvedeva; Centr notarial’nyh issledovanij pri Federal’noj notarial’noj palate. – 3-e izd., pererab. i dop. – Moscow: Statut, 2015.

14. Osnovy nasledstvennogo prava Rossii, Francii i Germanii [Fundamentals of Russia, France and Germany inheritance laws] / Pod obshch. red. E.YU. Petrova. – M.: Statut, 2015.

15. Hodykin R.M. Kriterij naibolee tesnoj svyazi v mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave [Criterion of the closest connection in private international law] / Hodykin R.M. // Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava. – 2002. – № 4.

16. Hodykin R.M. Istoriya i razvitie koncepcii naibolee tesnoj svyazi v mezhdunarodnom chastnom prave [History and development of the concept of the closest connection in private international law] / R.M. Hodykin // Pravo i mezhdunarodnye ehkonomicheskie otnosheniya. Sbornik statej / Otv. red. N.G. Doronina. – M.: Yurist, 2005.

17. Bonomi A., Wautelet P. Le droit européen des successions: Commentaire du Règlement № 650/2012 du 4 juillet 2012 [European Law of Succession: Commentary to the Regulation (EU) № 650/2012 of 4 July 2012] / A. Bonomi, Wautelet P., Oztürk A., Petelli I. – 2ème édition. – Bruylant, 2015.

18. Guide de droit international privé des successions [Guide on private international law of succession] / Dan Andrei Popescu, Maître de conférences; trad.: Loredana Vlăsceanu - Oneşti: Magic Print, 2014.

19. Lequette Y. Le droit international privé de la famille à l’épreuve des conventions internationales [Private international law of the family to the test of international conventions] / Y. Lequette // Recueil des Cours de l’Académie de droit international de la Haye (Vol. 246), 1994.