The 25th Amendment and Presidential Succession: A Constitutional Analysis in Light of Recent Debates

INTRODUCTION. This comprehensive analysis examines the 25th Amendment of the United States Constitution, focusing on its historical context, current political relevance, and potential implications for American governance. The study explores the amendment's provisions for presidential succession and incapacity against the backdrop of contemporary political debates.

MATERIAL AND METHODS. The research employs a multidisciplinary methodology combining historical analysis of presidential incapacity cases, a comprehensive literature review of constitutional law and governance studies, evaluation of ethical implications through democratic theory, and examination of current political discourse surrounding the amendment.

RESEARCH RESULTS. The study reveals the complex interplay between the amendment's four sections and their practical applications, highlighting the unprecedented nature of Section 4's potential invocation. Analysis demonstrates significant legal costs associated with its implementation, including institutional strain between branches of government, challenges to democratic legitimacy, and the establishment of potentially problematic precedents for future executive-legislative relations.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS. The findings underscore that the 25th Amendment represents both a constitutional safeguard and a complex governance challenge, requiring delicate navigation of legal frameworks, political realities, and ethical considerations. The potential invocation of Section 4 carries profound implications for separation of powers, democratic norms, and constitutional interpretation that extend well beyond immediate political considerations. This analysis illuminates the amendment's dual nature as both solution and challenge to the American constitutional system.

1. Abrams H.L. ‘The President Has Been Shot’: Confusion, Disability, and the 25th Amendment. Stanford University Press. 1994.

2. Ackerman B. The decline and fall of the American republic. Harvard University Press. 2010. Т. 12.

3. Amar A.R. America's constitution: A biography. Random House Incorporated. 2005.

4. Amar A.R. The Words that Made Us: America's Constitutional Conversation. 1760 –1840. Basic Books. 2021.

5. Annas G.J., Grodin M.A. Reflections on the 70th anniversary of the Nuremberg doctors’ trial. – American journal of public health. 2018. No. 1. Issue 108. P. 10-12.

6. Azari J. Weak Parties, Strong Partisanship. – The Making of the Presidential Candidates. 2024.

7. Berger S.A. The President's Brain: Executive Function and the Challenges of Cognitive Aging. – Political Psychology. 2021. No. 3. Issue 42. P. 441-458.

8. Bowman F.O. The Constitutional Case for Impeaching Donald Trump [Again]. The University of Missouri School of Law. Legal Studies Research Paper Series. 2021.

9. Cannon L. President Reagan: The role of a lifetime. Hachette UK. 2008.

10. Carothers T. Democracy Support in Hard Places. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. 2022.

11. Conklin M. Eisenhower's Stroke: The Call for a “Fully Functioning” Vice President. – Presidential Studies Quarterly. 2016. No. 1. Issue 46. P. 89-112.

12. Cooper Jr.J.M. Woodrow Wilson. Vintage. 2009.

13. Diamond L. Ill winds: Saving democracy from Russian rage, Chinese ambition, and American complacency. Penguin. 2020.

14. Drezner D.W. The toddler in chief: What Donald Trump teaches us about the modern presidency. University of Chicago Press. 2020.

15. Enten H. The Role of Age in Presidential Politics: A Statistical Analysis. – Electoral Studies. 2022. No. 81.

16. Feerick J.D. The twenty-fifth amendment: Its complete history and applications. Fordham University Press. 2022.

17. Gilbert R.E. The Politics of Presidential Medical Care: Ronald Reagan and the 25th Amendment. – Politics and the Life Sciences. 2020. T. 39. No. 1. P. 40-53.

18. Goldstein J.K. The Modern American Vice Presidency: The Transformation of a Political Institution. Princeton University Press. 1982.

19. Goldstein J.K. The White House vice presidency: The path to significance, Mondale to Biden. University Press of Kansas. 2017.

20. Gould L.L. The modern American presidency. University Press of Kansas. 2009.

21. Hetherington M.J., Rudolph T.J. Why Washington won't work: Polarization, political trust, and the governing crisis. – Why Washington Won't Work. University of Chicago Press. 2015.

22. Jamieson K.H. Cyberwar: how Russian hackers and trolls helped elect a president: what we don't, can't, and do know. Oxford University Press. 2020.

23. Kalt B.C. Constitutional Cliffhangers: A Legal Guide for Presidents and Their Enemies. Yale University Press. 2012.

24. Kalt B. C. Unable: The Law, Politics, and Limits of Section 4 of the Twenty-Fifth Amendment. Oxford University Press. 2019.

25. Kalt B.C. The Twenty-fifth Amendment and Incapacity from Outside Force. – Fordham Law Review. 2021. No. 5. Issue 89. Р. 1951-1974.

26. Kassop N. The Twenty-fifth Amendment: Its Crafting and Use Today. – Presidential Studies Quarterly. 2020. No. 3. Issue 50. P. 712-732.

27. Lachman V.D. Ethical challenges in the era of health care reform. – MedSurg Nursing. 2012. No. 4. Issue 21. P. 248.

28. Levi M., Stoker L. Political trust and trustworthiness. – Annual review of political science. 2000. No. 1. Issue 3. P. 475-507.

29. Levinson S., Balkin J.M. Democracy and dysfunction. University of Chicago Press. 2019.

30. McDermott R. Presidential leadership, illness, and decision making. Cambridge University Press. 2007.

31. Neale T.H. Presidential Disability Under the Twenty-Fifth Amendment: Constitutional Provisions and Perspectives for Congress. – Congressional Research Service. 2018. Vol. 45394.

32. Posner E.A., Vermeule A. The executive unbound: after the madisonian republic. Oxford University Press. 2018.

33. Tribe L., Matz J. To end a presidency: the power of impeachment. Hachette UK. 2018.

34. Tumber H., Zelizer B. Special 20th anniversary issue: The challenges facing journalism today. –Journalism. 2019. No. 1. Issue 20. P. 5-7.